Graham McNeill's Weblog
Wednesday, May 26, 2010
Entertainment Weakly
Lost is...over..sniff...
Okay, so the sixth season of Lost aired on Monday, and, having watched the penultimate episode only the night before I was primed and ready for it. I'll go into specifics in a second, but let me first up say that I loved the way the show ended. It did everything I needed it to, providing me with emotional highs, closure to the main story arcs and a sense that there was still more I could read into the story, still more I could gather round the water cooler (If I had one) to talk about what it all meant.
After six years and so many sprawling plot lines, it was inevitable that some questions would remain unanswered, but you know what? That's absolutely fine. That's Lost. If everything had been tied in a neat bow, fed to me on a silver spoon, I'd have been disappointed. There's still aspects of the show I don't know and probably never will, and I'm okay with that. What was the golden light, who was Jacob and MiB's mother, what was the deal with Walt? To name a few. But the show's strength was always its characters and the writers and actors imbued them all with real depth and warmth that made me really care about them. I've lived and breathed alongside them on that island, and to see their fates played out before me gave me many moments of triumph along the way. Seeing Claire and Charlie reunited at the concert during Aaron's birth had me blubbing like a little girl, as did Sun and Jin's reveal - even though it included scenes of their death. And Jack's, 'I'll see you in another life, brother,' line in the cave turned me into a wreck.
Watching Jack and Locke brawling on the cliff in the rain was just amazing, with its shades of 300, and the symmetry of so many images throughout the episode spoke of such carefully crafted plotting that I sat in real admiration of J.J. Abrams, Carlton Cuse, Damon Lindelof and all the other writers. Watching characters I'd grown to love over the six year run of the show meet their fates, grisly or otherwise, was a real treat, and I don't think I've invested in a show as much as I did Lost.
And the ending. Finding out that the Flash Sideways were a kind of celestial waiting room, where all the characters had to find themselves to 'let go' and move on was a stroke of genius, as it made sense of the strange connections established in what I had assumed was a cracked, parallel time line established by the detonation of the hydrogen bomb at the end of Season 5 (which, as it now turns out, clearly didn't go off...). I guess a lot of folk read this as confirming the suspicions many had early on that everyone died in the crash and that the island was some form of Purgatory, but Christian spells it out for Jack, that everyone had to find each other, and that what happened on the island really happened. In a lovely piece of symmetry from the opening episode, we saw Jack lying in the bamboo field, and where we begin with his eye opening, we end with it closing. Perfect. Oh, and the dog lives too. Jerry Bruckheimer would be proud.
So, emotional journeys, wonderful character moments and a sense of closure. I couldn't ask for anything more, though I have to say that I felt kind of sorry for the Man in Black. Yeah, he did some terrible things along the way, but didn't he just want to leave the island after glimpsing the possibility that there was life beyond its shores? Perhaps as Old Smokey he really shouldn't have left...great evil, blah, blah, blah, but perhaps if his mother had just let him go in the first place, all this could have been avoided. Yeah, and if they'd given Gwaihir the Ring there'd have been no trek across Middle Earth. And wouldn't that have been boring? That's what I thought of Lost's finale, what did you think? Genius, dross, not enough answers, satisfying in every way...? Let me know.
Farewell Lost, I'm going back to the Season 1 box set to start again, armed with the knowledge of what's really going on...
Paul Gray
And in other news, I read that Paul Gray, the bassist for Slipknot was found dead on May 24th, which made me pretty sad, as I'm a big fan of the band. Having just watched BBC2's documentary "I'm in a Rock & Roll Band", I've developed a newfound respect for the bass player, the so-called, 'other one'. Often without the fiery charisma of the lead singer, furious noodling of the lead guitarist or pounding aggression of the drummer, they were sort of the quiet ones at the back.
There are of course, some obvious exceptions, like Gene Simmons, Geddy Lee, Paul Simonon, Peter 'Hooky' Hook, Steve Harris and, of course, Mark Gibbons. And if you don't know who any of these guys are, Google them now.
So you ignore the bassist at your peril, for a powerful bassline anchors the greatest rock songs. Just look at Ace of Spades. I know Slipknot weren't to everyone's tastes, but when they exploded onto the scene with their self-titled album in 1999, it was like a hand grenade in the midst of bloated stadium bands that shook the world of rock and metal to its core. I equate their impact to that of Nirvana, who did something similar, playing a stripped back rock that was powerful in its simplicity and lo-fi approach to rock. Anyway, this Maggot wishes Paul's soul well wherever it is now. Maybe he's meeting up with Jon Bonham, Keith Moon and Kurt Cobain before moving on...
Cancellations
Don't you hate it when you're just getting into a show and the network pulls the plug? Why is it that dross like Two and a Half Men (A show by Chuck Lorre, whose other work, The Big Bang Theory, I love) and the innumerable cop procedurals get into their tenth seasons and beyond, while shows that demand a bit of investment and eye-on-the-ball smarts get canceled before they have a chance to grow? Shows like Flash Forward, Firefly, Invasion etc... I understand that the American TV landscape is a harsh place, where cut-throat execs roam with their snipping shears of doom, but it seems to me that by canceling shows that don't hit stratospheric numbers of viewers they're actually shooting themselves in the foot.
Now it seems to me that you get a lot of people watching a new show, then there's obviously going to be some drop off from the fly-by-nighters who aren't interested in continuing, but there's a loyal core of fans who
get
the show and stick with it, loyally tuning in every week to see what happens next. Aren't they the ones you're sticking it to by canceling the show, the ones who stuck with you and put their faith in its potential? It's a rare tv show that gets to choose its time to end. The Wire did it beautifully, BSG did it well, as did Buffy, and as I mentioned above, Lost managed it too. To an extent Angel did it too, though a lot of what went into the ending was a tad rushed and the open-ended charge into the monsters felt a little...unconvincing as a finale. Listening to Joss Whedon's commentary for that final episode, I can see his point that it's representing the fact that the battle against evil never ends, but it still left a sour taste in my mouth, like that explanation was bent to fit how they ended the episode.
Take Flash Forward for example. It started well, and though, admittedly, sagged a tad in the middle - not helped by a mid-season break in a terribly chosen spot - it was picking up pace toward the end and was establishing a nice balance between dangling bemusing threads and answering some of the earlier questions. And then it gets canceled. Arse. We've yet to watch the final episode, though I read that it's been edited and put together in such a way as to provide some element of closure to its multiple plot lines since the show's producers knew they weren't going to get any more episodes. We'll see. And 24, another of my favourite shows, is ending soon too (can I take the trauma of so many cancellations!?). We'll see how they end that in a convincing way, though knowing Jack, it's going to be ridiculously over the top, violent and with plenty of utterances of the word Dammit! Which is just how I want my Jack Bauer.
Right, back to work now, and I promise I'll have something vaguely writing related to talk about next time.
5/26/2010 5:22:52 PM (GMT Daylight Time, UTC+01:00)
Comments [23]
Trackback
Tracked by:
http://topsy.com/trackback?utm_source=pingback&utm_campaign=L2&url=http://www.gr...
[Pingback]
5/27/2010 12:19:27 AM (GMT Daylight Time, UTC+01:00)
There was a drama called 'The Lyons Den' which ran a few years back which is semi-famous for the surreal nature of its ending, owing to the kind of premature cancellation you're talking about here. It had Rob Lowe as a high-powered lawyer, a sort of prisoner of conscience in a firm up to its eyeballs in the shady dealings. He'd end up representing various scumbags from amongst his firms clientele while separately maintaining various pro bono cases for the wronged in society, the inevitable connections between which slowly revealed to him the depths of complicity between politicians, lawyers and big business. It was mostly over-the-top conspiracy nonsense but had some interesting stuff in about ethical grey areas, where there's plenty that might not be strictly illegal, but no one would want you to find out about anyway. It set its stall out as a courtroom drama with a continuing storyline, rather than a series of one-off cases, thus making a full series pretty much a requisite, but predictably got cancelled halfway through.
I doubt many people were watching by the time it did, but the creators at least had the last laugh. The vested interests who served as the bad guys in the series would always try to scare the Rob Lowe character off by threatening to blacken his name - he had a bit of a runaway youth, so it was easy done. The story they dredged up and continually threatend to use was to do with a young woman who drowned during a party on his father's yacht, fifteen or twenty years earlier. His father being a senator, the powers-that-be were out to construct some story of Rob Lowe's character having killed the girl before covering it up with his father's assistance. All of which was nonsense, of course, until the last episode when, knowing they'd been cancelled, they had Rob Lowe brutally murder half a dozen people before calling his father up to say, "Dad, it's happened again." And that was that.
It wasn't an especially notable moment in TV history overall, but it was reasonably smart, and probably with more of a chance of justifying itself in the long-run than most of the abortive rubbish on TV, so I thought the creators using the void last episode to say, "What do you expect if you don't even let us get to the end of the story?" was pretty spot-on.
Matt Keefe
5/28/2010 8:33:05 AM (GMT Daylight Time, UTC+01:00)
Nice insight, I'm still only 3 seasons deep into Lost, so I can't judge how well that ended up. As a keen follower of yours and your work on 40K I was pleasantly surprised that you also seem to enjoy the works of Joss Whedon, my personal TV favourite. I never cease to be amazed by how many classy people see beyond the surface and appreciate the more (but also less) subtle aspects of his work. Glad you're one of them. What did you think of Dollhouse? I was disappointed at first, but having seen the last few episodes I had to admit. Joss still has it... give him a chance SOMEONE :-D
PS I REALLY need to get a hold of Chapter's Due :-) Looking forward to anything else you have approaching. (HH anyone? :-))
Filip Janik
|
filip_janikAT NOSPAMhotmail dot com
5/28/2010 11:06:49 AM (GMT Daylight Time, UTC+01:00)
I too enjoyed the ending of Lost....and I cried like a little girl with a skinned knee at the ending. It was terribly embarrassing. But it was that which made up for the fact that there was a great deal left unanswered. But had it ended any other way, it would have been as good.
One of my co-workers and fellow Lost fans (possibly former) HATED how it ended and it's really funny to watch him get rather angry over how it ended....though I try not to laugh at him in case it made his annoyance worse.
Not seen the ender of 24 yet, that will be watched this evening....but again, I fear there may be tears, and since I watch 24 with my mum, I'm not impressed at that possibility. But the same co-work has been raving over the 24 ender and he's a little dismayed that he can't say anything about it because I've not see it yet. It will be the topic of conversation between us on Saturday morning though....if he's in on that morning.
Cancellation of Flash Forward, I'm not sure about as I've not watched the last couple of episodes due to illness and being distracted to the point where I missed the repeated episode that's shown just before the new one on Monday. But it has been flagging a little from the edge-of-your-seat stuff that it started out with. If I can manage it I'll watch the finale, but I'm not going to push myself for it.
And then on the flip side of this, you have Supernatural. Which was only supposed to be 5 seasons, but due to popularity and dollar signs, it's been commissioned for a 6th season. So rather than having a blistering finale, it had a rather tacked together season ender, which I thought was wholly disappointing....and Supernatural has always had awesome, fist-in-your-mouth season enders. So I find myself somewhat disenchanted with the idea of season 6, though I'll give it a try when it comes back to see what they do with it.
But after watching Lost, the urge to get out season one and start watching it again was pretty high, and I would have....had it not be 1am when I finished the finale. But once I've stopped doing stuff, I'll watch them all again from the beginning.
Xhalax
|
daemonifugeAT NOSPAMhotmail dot com
6/2/2010 4:22:26 PM (GMT Daylight Time, UTC+01:00)
I felt sorry for the Man In Black too. I saw it as though his Mother purposely raised him and Jacob that way, so that he would end up killing her and she could be free.
I also think that the show answered the important questions and left the rest for the fans to decide on themselves.
I can't wait til the box set is out so I can watch it all from start to finish.
Phil W
|
calebazathothAT NOSPAMgmail dot com
6/7/2010 9:01:02 PM (GMT Daylight Time, UTC+01:00)
On a completely different note, Mr. McNeill...I think I've discovered that our dog is a fan of yours. I've just been sitting reading Courage and Honour to him for the last 45 minutes and he never budged a muscle until there was the sound of his supper from downstairs.
Now the dog-beast doesn't really like me all that much and never comes and sits with me for more than 5 minutes, but when I picked up the book to go upstairs and read, he followed me. So I sat and read it to him.
If memory served, I read portions of The Killing Ground to him last year while out in the back garden.
Xhalax
|
daemonifugeAT NOSPAMhotmail dot com
6/10/2010 1:14:53 PM (GMT Daylight Time, UTC+01:00)
Lost
I really enjoyed how Lost ended. It's been hard to find anyone with a good word to say about it, and most of the people I used to enjoy talking 'round the water cooler' about it lost (arf) interest with it. I can see why, it did (I'm not doing this on purpose) lose its way. A lot of the last series was excruciating as the scriptwriters put teasing us above plot to ensure 90% of dialogue was questions and constipated/soul-searching looks and 0% answers. it was like the second Matrix film, where Keanu wanders around saying "what am I supposed to do?" and gets 100 different ways of saying "what you are supposed to do." ugh. However, considering that, I thought they worked tied it up well.
I also felt a bit sorry for the Man In Black, for the reasons already mentioned, but also because he became Locke, who was just awesome.
Cancellations
It's getting serious now, what the hell am I going to watch?
Flash Forward was excellent, but much like Heroes paid the price for losing viewers in the middle. The last few episodes of FF were excellent and despite what they suggested, it was a massively open-ended monstrous cliffhanger to leave it on. Similarly, I thought the last series of Heroes was thoroughly excellent, even going so far to say I thought it was better than the first. It's a shame that the TV world is so heartless, but they do love their money and there's nothing like playing it safe to keep it coming in (see also: most British comedy).
Seriously though, with Lost, BSG, 24, Heroes and Flash Forward done, what else is there. I can't live on Battlestar Galact - I mean Stargate Universe alone! What do I watch now?!
Paul Gray
Sadtimes. The grim reaper's got it in for the heavy rock world, clearly. However reluctant people are to acknowledge their impact because of the masks and tone, they changed the face of metal with their style, ferocity and success. And they changed it for the better. They made it into the UK charts when it was still nothing but boy bands and rap/(fake)RnB dominating, which is a massive feat. He'll be sadly missed and I think it's probably better if they call it quits.
Top bloggage, sir!
Phill
|
engin_no9AT NOSPAMhotmail dot com
6/12/2010 7:17:15 AM (GMT Daylight Time, UTC+01:00)
I was very pleased to find this site.I wanted to thank you for this great read!! I definitely enjoying every little bit of it and I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you post.
Oxygen Plant
|
bibhu dot nucleusAT NOSPAMgmail dot com
11/22/2010 5:27:40 AM (GMT Standard Time, UTC+00:00)
We are renowned as the Manufacturer of Oxygen Plants, Nitrogen Plants and Acetylene plants.
oxygen plants
|
oxyplantsAT NOSPAMgmail dot com
7/16/2011 6:57:53 AM (GMT Daylight Time, UTC+01:00)
I might be betaing a dead horse, but thank you for posting this!
Tawny
|
valerieAT NOSPAMvaleriepowell dot com
7/17/2011 4:45:52 PM (GMT Daylight Time, UTC+01:00)
9e1vI5 , [url=http://ouszagmqbgvx.com/]ouszagmqbgvx[/url], [link=http://pasyzqrcenha.com/]pasyzqrcenha[/link], http://boajuoykffhj.com/
ovyhrfoswta
|
ngrulpAT NOSPAMcheapp dot com
7/22/2011 2:23:31 AM (GMT Daylight Time, UTC+01:00)
fiorcet generic ultram wellbutrin zoloft 11382 viagra =]
zachnear
|
nkk-uehara dot kAT NOSPAMspace dot ocn dot ne dot jp
7/22/2011 5:23:45 AM (GMT Daylight Time, UTC+01:00)
insurance home 644 home insurance %-)))
phalxor
|
porusheAT NOSPAMokashigoten dot com
7/30/2011 1:50:29 AM (GMT Daylight Time, UTC+01:00)
home insurance :-DD american life insurance company :-[[ life insurance for seniors hutd
liltonky
|
tatsu-ymAT NOSPAMsouthernx dot ne dot jp
7/30/2011 4:02:06 AM (GMT Daylight Time, UTC+01:00)
life insurance policy >:-PPP life insurance quotes tyo
DarkAngelAbs
|
uehara-tadashiAT NOSPAMtkcnf dot or dot jp
8/7/2011 4:10:02 AM (GMT Daylight Time, UTC+01:00)
propecia pills saeqlc cymbalta on line myov
lornapl
|
gima dot tunesadaAT NOSPAMtkcnf dot or dot jp
8/7/2011 7:00:15 AM (GMT Daylight Time, UTC+01:00)
buy tramadol without priscription gsov Cialis xjxubi
bodylogic
|
qqde29z9nAT NOSPAMwater dot ocn dot ne dot jp
8/11/2011 2:00:44 AM (GMT Daylight Time, UTC+01:00)
eastwood auto insurance kcng cheap car insurance lrv
hotdog55u
|
infoAT NOSPAMnahakojin dot jp
8/12/2011 2:09:01 AM (GMT Daylight Time, UTC+01:00)
car insurance quotes >:DDD home insurance dqdrso
Maria9ta
|
okinawaAT NOSPAMokinawa-sec dot co dot jp
8/12/2011 5:07:02 AM (GMT Daylight Time, UTC+01:00)
personal health insurance 553 auto insurance quotes 2049
chantymusic
|
itojikouAT NOSPAMd1 dot dion dot ne dot jp
8/13/2011 5:00:29 AM (GMT Daylight Time, UTC+01:00)
Cialis 541917 levitra ylys
ergace
|
trustec2041AT NOSPAMyahoo dot co dot jp
8/13/2011 10:31:01 AM (GMT Daylight Time, UTC+01:00)
cheap health insurance swgs car insurance quotes fzqjv
TRUUTHZ
|
agoraAT NOSPAMhirai dot ne dot jp
8/14/2011 4:17:03 AM (GMT Daylight Time, UTC+01:00)
car insurance rates 263 business insurance 393
sonysystem
|
fsoAT NOSPAMmco dot ne dot jp
8/15/2011 12:38:43 AM (GMT Daylight Time, UTC+01:00)
prednisone :PP priligy without prescription 396
xDawesomexD
|
infoAT NOSPAMkainan dot com
Name
E-mail
Home page
Remember Me
Comment (HTML not allowed)
Enter the code shown (prevents robots):
© Copyright 2012 Graham mcneill Unless stated
Theme design by
Bryan Bell
newtelligence dasBlog 1.8.5223.2
|
|
| Page rendered at 2/4/2012 8:00:09 PM (GMT Standard Time, UTC+00:00)
Pick a theme:
BlogXP
calmBlue
Candid Blue
dasBlog
Discreet Blog Blue
Elegante
essence
Just Html
Mono
Movable Radio Blue
Movable Radio Heat
orangeCream
Portal
Project84
Slate
Sound Waves
Tricoleur
On this page....
<
February 2012
>
Sun
Mon
Tue
Wed
Thu
Fri
Sat
29
30
31
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Search
Navigation
Main Website
Home
Categories
Blogroll
Sign In